loading

Lepu Seal - A Professional China Mechanical Seal Manufacturer providing Cartridge Seal, Grundfos Mechanical Seal And We offer free sample!

mark@lepuseal.com+86 18903009893

How To Choose The Best Mechanical Seal For Your Pump

Master how to choose the best mechanical seal for pumps. Explore working principles, various seal types, common mistakes, and expert advice from Lepu Seal.

Table of Contents

Mechanical seals are the unsung heroes of today's fluid dynamics. They may be physically a small part of a large industrial system, but their role is of great importance. One failure of the seal can halt an entire production line, resulting in serious equipment downtime, serious environmental risks, and huge repair costs. Choosing the right one is no simple maintenance requirement, but a vital engineering necessity.

From a standard centrifugal water pump to a high-pressure petrochemical system, it's essential to be sure you have the correct solution. This complete guide will take a deep dive into how pumps work, explain the working principles of sealing technology, discuss various types of seals (from the elastomer bellows to the more robust cartridges), and identify the most prevalent selection mistakes to avoid.

Understanding Pump Operation

The first step to selecting the right mechanical seal is to know the environment in which it will be used and the pump itself. In industrial pumps like centrifugal and positive displacement pumps, Mechanical energy is converted into fluid energy using a very fast-rotating shaft. The basic engineering problem occurs at the point where this revolving shaft makes the transition to the stationary casing (the "wet end") of the pump. The clearance gap between the moving shaft and stationary casing must be adequate so that the extremely high-pressure process fluid can escape directly.

In the past, "gland packing" was used to seal this gap, a material made from a braid of rope tightly packed into the gap. Although it was a practical solution, the gland packing needed to be lubricated with a continuous, deliberate "controlled leak"; otherwise, function would be impaired, resulting in the loss of precious process fluid and energy as well as high and costly shaft wear over time.

The mechanical seal arrives, addressing the prevalent issue of leaking and offering a contemporary, efficient remedy. Mechanical seals offer a precise, nearly impermeable barrier to avert fluid contamination, considerably decrease energy usage, and reduce mechanical friction. This consequently enhances the pump's efficacy and the durability of its apparatus. The most important part of figuring out a good sealing solution is understanding this dynamic internal environment, including the system pressure, the pumping speed, and the actual chemical composition of the fluid that is being pumped.

The Working Principle of Mechanical Seals in Pumps

Mechanical seals are essentially a very engineered, tight fluid seal between two very flat surfaces. So how does it do this in reality?

A typical mechanical seal is made of three basic components that are harmoniously integrated:

Primary Seal (Seal Faces): This is the main part of the device. It has 2 very polished faces, one is fixed (stationary), and the other is rotating (fixed to the rotating pump shaft). The faces are tightly closed by a mechanical loading system and the hydraulic load of the fluid. The distance is extremely small: typically a hydrodynamic fluid film of only a few microns thickness lies between them. This extremely thin film lubricates the faces and keeps the faces from running dry but is thin enough to allow the process fluid to ensure it doesn’t 'drip out'.
The Secondary Sealing Element (O-rings or Bellows): These flexible components provide static sealing between the stationary face and the pump casing; they also provide rotating face-to-shaft sealing. They're usually manufactured from high-grade elastomers such as Viton, EPDM, or PTFE, and must be chemically compatible with the process fluid used.
Mechanical Loading Mechanism: Springs (Single or Multiple) or Flexible bellows (Metal or Elastomer) are used to ensure Primary Seals are in uniform contact and at all times. This mechanism will ensure any small microscopic wear on the seal faces over time, and will compensate for slight shaft run-out, vibration, or thermal expansion.

In this way, the balance of mechanical spring force and hydraulic fluid pressure provides secure closure of the seal under static conditions and a very thin protective fluid film during rotation.

Types of Mechanical Seals

There are many different types of pumping applications, and engineers have created different designs of seals for different pressures, temperatures, and fluid viscosities. The selection of the proper type is essential to the reliability of a system. The most common mechanical seal types, their particular engineering characteristics, and their application in the field are detailed below.

1. Cartridge Mechanical Seal

A cartridge mechanical seal is a complete pre-assembled combination of the seal, gland and sleeve. It alleviates the installation problems caused by humans since all the items are pre-set by the manufacturer. It has a simple "plug and play" design that allows it to be deployed quickly, making it ideal for general process pumps, API pumps, and applications requiring rapid maintenance turnaround to minimize costly facility downtime.

2. Metal Bellows Mechanical Seal

This seal does not use coil springs, but a solid welded metal bellows design. These mechanical seals have a high degree of temperature resistance and have no dynamic O-ring that may get hung up or that may lose efficiency over time. That's why it is the perfect material for use in high-temperature petrochemical processing, oil refineries, heat transfer fluids, and in chemically harsh environments.

3. Elastomer Bellow Mechanical Seal

This seal has a flexible rubber or elastomer bellow, excellent dynamic flexibility, and also protects the pump shaft. It self-adjusts to run-out of the shaft, and completely prevents shaft fretting. It is mostly used in wastewater treatment plants, sewage pumps, municipal water plants, and weak industrial slurry processing.

4. Single Spring Mechanical Seal

This is a well-known classic design with a single thick coil spring that provides face pressure. The large size and open structure of the spring make it very resistant to clogging due to suspended solids. It is an inexpensive, simple, and highly durable sealing solution. This seal is commonly used on heavy slurry pumps, paper and pulp, food and beverage manufacturing, and in highly viscous fluid transfers.

5. Double Spring (Multiple Spring) Seal

This design features several smaller springs evenly placed around the seal instead of just a single spring. This gives an extremely even face loading throughout the seal ring and reduces the amount of axial clearance within the pump casing. It is recommended for clean fluid transfer, chemical processing applications, and high-speed applications where uniformly distributed face pressure is a critical factor to maintain a leak-free system.

Key Considerations When Choosing a Mechanical Seal

Choosing a seal is not just about the size of the shaft. Engineers have to consider a wide array of variables to achieve the best performance and operational life. These are key factors to keep in mind while deciding on your options:

Chemical Compatibility & Viscosity: The fluid to be pumped determines the materials of construction. For pumping extremely corrosive acids, premium secondary elastomers such as FFKM and silicon carbide primary seal faces are required. Abrasive slurries, however, require hard-face materials such as Tungsten Carbide as they can take heavy wear. It is always best to consult precise chemical compatibility charts.
Operating Pressure and Temperature: These conditions define the mechanical limits of the seal. For low pressure, regular unbalanced seals can work great. But high pressure demands a balanced seal to provide a reduction of the force on the seal faces that will minimize the heat generated and vaporization. In addition, very hot temperatures necessitate Metal Bellows seals, as typical rubber-based seals may degrade or melt.
Industry Standards and Compliance: For critical applications such as hazardous chemical processing and oil & gas, stringent compliance with international standards such as API 682 or ISO 21049 is mandatory. The regulations call for some seal designs (single, double, or tandem containment seals) and environmental controls to keep emissions from the seals and items as safe as possible.
Shaft Speed and Equipment Vibration: High Rotational Shaft Speeds Result in Significant Frictional Heat. Equipment vibration is significant with high shaft speeds. In these cases, stationary multiple spring designs or very well-balanced cartridge seals are better. Furthermore, an Elastomer Bellow seal can provide the necessary flexibility needed to maintain proper seal face engagement without early failure when the pump is subjected to high-level vibration or shaft deflection.

Common Selection Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Experienced engineers and maintenance workers can be caught in traps when they are selecting sealing solutions. Below are the most prevalent mistakes in the industry and ways to avoid them:

Mistake 1: Ignoring the Environmental Support System (Flush Plans)

The seal is as good as the environment in which it's operating. If a suitable API flush plan is not in place (to remove abrasive particulates, to cool the seal, and increase the pressure), there will be quick dry running and catastrophic failure.
How to Avoid: Always carefully determine whether to use a dedicated barrier fluid, quench or flush system, depending on the fluid's volatility and specific heat.

Mistake 2: Choosing the Wrong Secondary Elastomer

If the O-ring was ordinary Nitrile (Buna-N), an application at high temperature (steam or chemical) would harden, shatter, or melt the O-ring, producing immediate leakage.
How to Avoid: Check the elastomer’s thermal characteristics and chemical composition against the process fluid to determine its maximum operating temperature.

Mistake 3: Prioritizing Initial Cost Over Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

The standard component seals are simpler and easier to make, but more expensive in the beginning and tedious to install. If the seal is slightly misaligned at initial startup, it can cause problems.
How to Avoid: Purchase pre-assembled Cartridge mechanical seals. They offer high up-front costs, but save a lot of money in the long term due to the fact that they eliminate human installation mistakes and costly plant downtime.

Mistake 4: Using Hard-on-Soft Faces for Abrasive Media

Using a Carbon vs. Ceramic face combination in a sand-laden fluid will shred the softer carbon face in a matter of hours.
How to Avoid: Use Hard-on-Hard face combinations (Tungsten Carbide vs. Silicon Carbide) when using abrasive media.

Conclusion

The selection of the optimum mechanical seal is a complex engineering job where the characteristics of the fluid, operational parameters, and mechanical design are perfectly balanced. With a knowledge of the basic actions in the pump operation, the different types of seals that are available and how to avoid some of the common pitfalls of selection, plant managers and engineers can dramatically enhance the reliability of equipment, offer a safe and hygienic environment and reduce maintenance costs.

A wise business approach is to source these vital components from a highly renowned skilled Mechanical Seal Manufacturer. This is what really distinguishes Lepu Seal. Lepu Seal is a leading Mechanical Seal Supplier with a comprehensive and highly engineered range of high-quality mechanical seals such as world-class Cartridge Seals, Metal Bellows, Elastomer Bellows, and direct replacements for the renowned John Crane mechanical seals. Lepu Seal offers a customized solution, free samples, quick global delivery, and a successful history of application in the pulp, wastewater, food processing, and petroleum industries to protect your operations.

Upgrade the reliability of your equipment today and discover the true engineering excellence of a premium solution from John Crane's Lepu Seal partner.

FAQs

1. What is the precise difference between a balanced and an unbalanced mechanical seal?

If the seal is unbalanced, then the entire seal face area is subjected to the internal hydraulic pressure of the pump. This results in extremely high closing forces and substantial heat production, and thus can only be used for low pressure/clean applications. A balanced seal is designed in a way that allows a calculated part of the hydraulic pressure to be offset, which in turn will decrease the load on the seal faces. This allows a balanced seal to handle more pressure and speeds, with lower heat generation greatly increasing the life of the seal.

2. A mechanical seal in a pump should last for how long?

A properly installed mechanical seal running under ideal operating conditions (clean fluids, correct shaft alignment, proper installation, and adequate face lubrication) can maintain a life of roughly 25,000 to 40,000 operational hours (3 to 5 years). But in aggressive applications (high abrasiveness, temperature, dry running, etc), this could be much shorter if the wrong seal type or face material is ordered.

3. Can I upgrade and replace an old component seal with a new cartridge mechanical seal?

Yes, it is highly recommended to replace a standard component seal with a cartridge seal on the vast majority of modern industrial pumps. Cartridge seals are completely "built in the box," factory-made with seal, gland, and sleeve all in one piece. This removes the need for maintenance personnel to measure and adjust the compression of the spring on the shaft, which will significantly reduce the installation time and almost eliminate early failures due to human installation mistakes.

4. What is the most common cause of a mechanical seal leaking prematurely?

The absolute most common failure of seals is "dry running". It happens when the pump is not filled with enough fluid in the casing, causing the lubricating film between the seal faces to evaporate to an ultra-thin film. The frictional heat generated can cause the seal faces to shatter, warp, or be permanently damaged in seconds. Other significant factors are: wrong elastomer material used, high vibration on the shaft, and fine particles scratching the fine seal faces.

prev
How Do a Mechanical Seal Work: Complete Guide
Recommended Blog
Get in touch with us

Guangzhou Lepu Machinery Co., Ltd.


Add:

No. 5, Yunkai Road, Huangpu District, Guangzhou, China

Tel:

+86-020-36158139
+86-020-36158280

E-mail:
mark@lepuseal.com

Fax: +86-020-36158281

Contact Person: Mr. Mark Ao
Whatapps:
+86-18903009893

Contact Us
As a professional mechanical seal manufacturer, Lepu Seals is committed to providing complete mechanical seal solutions. We offer a wide range of sealing solutions for pumps in a variety of applications, including wastewater treatment, oil and gas, power generation, chemical, and other industries. We have provided mechanical seals to over 1,000 customers, with over 150 of them enjoying long-term partnerships. As the most widely used seal in the industry, our warehouse always has a sufficient supply of John Crane mechanical seals, and our capabilities ensure fast delivery.
Copyright © 2018 Guangzhou Lepu Machinery CO., LTD.  | Sitemap
Customer service